Skip to main content

Our Math Problem

Jeb HensarlingImage via Wikipedia
Our leaders, our political pundits (sadly including many of our conservative talk show hosts) and most especially members of Congress seem to have difficulty with math - and we have a major math problem.

While the focus is on the deficit - and that certainly is important - what really matters is the total debt. Let's look at the important numbers. The Federal Reserve yesterday released U.S. Household Net Worth. The sum of all the assets of all the household in the U.S., less the credit card, mortgage, auto loan, etc. debt is about $55.9 trillion. Since stocks and bonds are ultimately owned by individuals, that represents all the companies, certificates of deposits, houses, land, gold, jewelry, timber, automobiles, guns, baseball card collections, art, oil wells, farms, ranches, camp grounds, office towers, apartment buildings, malls, pensions, boats and motorcycles in the country.

On the other hand, the accumulated U. S. debt is $13,800,000,000,000. That is $13.8 trillion, but I think showing the string of zeroes illustrates the size of the math problem better. (See for a scary view.) Or, just under 25% of all American assets would be required to pay off the debt.

The U.S. government budget for fiscal year 2011 estimates receipts of $2,567,000,000,000 and spending of $3,834,000,000,000, or a $1.3 trillion deficit. Let's be optimistic and make the following assumptions: first, government receipts grow four percent a year every year. And second, we end the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, saving $200 billion a year, and we cut another $200 billion from spending. Further, we freeze every cost. That is, no raises to the military, no Social Security increases, no additional Medicare costs, and so on, or, that any such increases are offset by cuts somewhere else. As a result the 2012 deficit would be $833 billion (accumulated debt rises to $14,600,000,000,000). Costs would have to be frozen for 11 years, and revenue compound at four percent per year, to get to the first balanced year. If expenses grow at 2%, it takes 15 years to get to a balanced budget. Oh, and by the way, during that eleven years, another $6,600,000,000,000 is added to the debt before we get to that balanced budget.

I'd like to find a solution to the math problem that doesn't involve higher taxes, but I don't think that is math, it is magic, or worse, fraud. And if our elected officials have actually looked at the math, but tell us there is another way out, they are either lying hypocrites, or they need to tell us how it is going to work.

I listen to the attacks on the commission that was charged with proposing a solution and I am in turn shocked and disappointed. I watched Newt Gingrich - whom I admire- totally reject their recommendations because, in his view, they aren't sufficiently pro-growth. Newt - do you really think we are going to grow our way to a $500 billion surplus per year, for 28 consecutive years, to pay off the debt?

I watched TX Congressman Jeb Hensarling categorically reject the commission because it didn't deal with ObamaCare. Well, Congressman, there already is a $14 trillion hole to fill before that, so your position seems disingenuous to me. Or, perhaps you've been teaching your children to read, write and speak Chinese, since that is who they will soon be working for, therefore they're prepared and you really don't have to worry about it.

Annual after tax income from all households is now $11.4 trillion per year. The national debt represents 120% of national after tax income (at current tax rates).

The Commission's proposal to deal with the problem with a mix of two-thirds spending cuts and one-third revenue increases seems logical to me. I was pleased with Rush Limbaugh's initial response, which was pragmatic enough to recognize that this doesn't get resolved without some pain. If anything Mr. Limbaugh is a successful businessman, and can run the numbers.

To those that say raising taxes in a recession is a bad idea, I say yes, that is true, but leaving my baby granddaughter a bill for $14 trillion plus is equally a bad idea. And gradually making Americans indentured servants to the Chinese via getting them to keep buying our debt, is the worst idea of all.

One way out is inflation. By running the inflation rate up, government receipts don't grow four percent, but ten or twelve percent, and the debt gets paid with devalued dollars. The gold and silver markets are certainly signaling concern that is indeed what will happen. There is also the banana republic way out: the country simply declares its inability to pay and stops paying. That generally has a calamitous impact on the population; nonetheless it has been done numerous times.

The third path is the path of math and hard decisions: cut spending, raise taxes, reduce regulations and increase growth. The goal must be that everyone feels a little skinned. The Congressional pet projects get eliminated, the military, Social Security and Medicaid programs get cut, taxes get higher, in my ideal world some government departments and agencies get eliminated in their entirety, and major changes are made in the regulatory regimes.

OK Congress, time to get your calculators out. The good news for you is that this isn't a polynomial problem, a quadratic equation, and definitely not calculus. It is arithmetic with a little compound interest calculation. Time to do your homework assignment and come in with your math problem worked.

Enhanced by Zemanta


Popular posts from this blog

Book Review: What Matters Now by Gary Hamel

Interview of Eric Schmidt by Gary Hamel at the MLab dinner tonight. Google's Marissa Mayer and Hal Varian also joined the open dialog about Google's culture and management style, from chaos to arrogance. The video just went up on YouTube. It's quite entertaining. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)Cover of The Future of ManagementMy list of must-read business writers continues to expand.Gary Hamel, however, author of What Matters Now, with the very long subtitle of How to Win in a World of Relentless Change, Ferocious Competition, and Unstoppable Innovation, has been on the list for quite some time.Continuing his thesis on the need for a new approach to management introduced in his prior book The Future of Management, Hamel calls for a complete rethinking of how enterprises are run.

Fundamental to his recommendation is that the practice of management is ossified in a command and control system that is now generations old and needs to be replaced with something that reflects an educat…

Add This Great Work to Your History Bookshelf

Team of Rivals: The Political Genius of Abraham Lincoln (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
The more I study American history, the more I realize how little I really know. I just completed Doris Kearns Goodwin’s Team of Rivals in which she explores the inter-workings, personalities and politics of the Lincoln administration.Every American schoolboy or schoolgirl knows that Lincoln presided over the most difficult period in American history save the George Washington era.Most know that he struggled with a series of second rate generals until Grant emerged. And that he was tragically assassinated just as the War Between the States ended. But how many of us know that many of the cabinet members opposed Lincoln in the primary?That many of those thought he was unqualified for the office?That one of them – Salmon Chase – actually tried to build support to oppose Lincoln in the 1864 election?Or that Lincoln’s opponent in 1864 was former General McClelland, who so famously failed to take advantage of his…

New Research on How to Use Exercise to Grow a Bigger Brain

The Good News We’re swamped with research on how to grow and maintain a bigger brain into old age. Much of the research emphasizes exercise as essential to brain health at every age. Here’s a summary of relevant baseline research, then we’ll move to some new, interesting and thought-provoking research. Background Dr. Carl Cotman and Dr. Nicole Berchtold of the University of California Institute for Brain Aging and Dementia performed research on aerobic exercise and brain health. Cotman and Berchtold concentrated on “brain-derived neurotrophic factor” (BDNF). Because, in their words “it supports the survival and growth of many neuronal subtypes, including glutamatergic neurons”. In our (very) layman understanding, BDNF is a protein that helps nerve cells do, well, a lot. Grow in particular, as well as get stronger and avoid premature cellular death. Cotman and Berchtold learned that the act of consistent exercise increased levels of BNDF in the hippocampus. This finding was important, b…